Meter is not an intellectual practice. Neither is it a philosophical or political one. It is a rhythmic one only. You cannot think it to death. Nor can you build a school or party around it. Although you can dance to it.
What has me thinking this way is a conversation I’ve been having with Mike Snider concerning a hexameter line he has written in an otherwise iambic pentameter poem. He’s defending it. I’m suggesting it needs to be fixed.
Which is an interesting turn of events. Mike is much more the formalista than myself. He’s much more intellectual about the genre than myself. And maybe that’s the heart of the conversation. He’s defending his meter on an intellectual basis. And I’m arguing from a more impressionistic one.
Meter has little to do with the meaning of poetry. Or a poem. Although it can subliminally reinforce or oppose that meaning. Mike wants to reinforce an idea in the poem. And usually I love such a twist, especially when it does so in such an outlaw fashion as adding a foot in a line. But in this case I think Mike is arguing for a hypermetric reading intellectually, when on a more physical level the line feels metrically sound.
When establishing a meter, you establish a rhythm, and in such a dance, the body takes command over the intellect. If there’s a way the body can find five beats in a line, it will. Which is why, I’m not against substitutions and their ilk. The feet will find the foot. But you cannot intellectually convince the body there’s an extra foot (or even less a foot) when it’s begun to dance in pentameter. If it expects five feet, it will find five feet if at all possible. It will always side with the rhythm. You will have to damn well add a stong unmistakable extra foot in order to trip the body up and say hey!
It is projective in that manner. And expectant. Yet mostly rhythmic. But it is not intellectual, philosophical, or political. Which is why any arguments concerning the preference of meter to anything else is in the end a dead end. You can’t argue with the body. Either it likes the dance or it doesn’t. Mike and I will have to agree to disagree on an intellectual level here. But on a more physical one, well let the dance continue.
CLEAR WATER
-
I have mentioned this very simple summer hokku in at least two previous
postings, but never explained how or why it “works.” So here it is again,
re-transl...
5 weeks ago